The population of the former steel mill city of Johnstown, Pennsylvania, has been dropping roughly 1% every year for the last quarter century. The message to high schoolers is typically, if you want to get a well-paid job, consider leaving, perhaps to nearby Pittsburgh. A local community bank is hoping to change that perception with a new registered apprenticeship program that will roll out next fall.
The Big Idea: The program, sponsored by 1st Summit Bank, aims to recruit seniors in high school who want to stay in their hometown. Apprentices will enroll in the local community college, Pennsylvania Highlands Community College, and earn an associate degree in banking on the bank’s dime. They will simultaneously work and get paid, rotating through different departments before specializing. Upon completion of the three-year training program, the apprentices are guaranteed a full-time job for seven years.
“Young people need a sense of certainty that they just don’t feel anymore,” says Allison Johnson, the bank’s CEO and CFO. “Once they get through the apprenticeship, a big enticing feature of this program is that we’re going to offer them that job.”
In addition to the job guarantee, the bank is also planning to offer apprentices help with buying a home to further cement their intention of staying in the community. The plan is to provide down-payment assistance and offer mortgages at lower than the market rate.
1st Summit Bank has been in the community for over 100 years, but according to Johnson, it’s been getting harder and harder to find and retain new hires. Instead of poaching them from other banks in the region, Johnson believes that 1st Summit Bank—and other community banks in the area—need to grow their own talent. She expects the apprenticeship program, called ASCEND 250, to be a win-win for the bank and for Johnstown’s young people. It will also shepherd the bank into a new era where the four-year degree is not a barrier to entry, Johnson says.
“The amount of debt young people have to go into to get a four-year degree and then not to have a guaranteed job at the end, it just doesn’t make a lot of sense,” she says. “Having a four-year degree doesn’t necessarily mean a lot. They still don’t know anything about running a bank, so you’re starting from scratch anyway. This is a way to provide them with job security and a future, but we’re training them from day one.”
Grow Your Own
The banking industry makes up a small percentage of registered apprenticeships, but it has been growing in recent years as apprenticeships have branched out from the trades and construction. Last year, there were 155 registered apprentices actively training in the field, compared to 95 in 2021, according to analysis by the Urban Institute—and there are larger numbers of apprentices in unregistered programs. Local credit unions are among those with apprenticeship programs, but large national banks lead the pack in sheer numbers.
This fall, Bank of America announced it will hire 1K new apprentices on top of the 800 a year it already hires, though none of the apprenticeships are registered. Wells Fargo also has a robust apprenticeship program for military veterans that gives them the opportunity to apprentice as branch managers. Outside of Wells Fargo’s program, the largest share of registered apprentices in banking train to be tellers.
Youth apprenticeships are also breaking into nontraditional fields, including banking. In Indiana’s new statewide Swiss-style youth apprenticeship program, banking is one of the core industries the state is focused on.
ASCEND 250 plans to hire about 10 apprentices a year. They’ll start by spending the first 18 months rotating through different departments, including human resources, marketing, and operations. For the second half of the program, apprentices will pick a specialization based on their interests and the bank’s needs.
Johnson sits on a roundtable with other community bank CEOs in the Pittsburgh area, and staffing and talent acquisition are perennial issues they discuss. Typically, the banks will try to draw in talent from other banks with better offers, but when the hires are not from the area, they often don’t stay, Johnson says. According to the Independent Community Bankers of America, community banks’ biggest competitors are other community banks. The apprenticeship program aims to shrink some of the competition for talent and hopefully inspire other banks to start similar programs.
“If we’re going to get that talent and get them to stay, we’re going to have to build it as opposed to buying it,” Johnson says.
State Apprenticeship Challenges: ASCEND 250 has gotten the support of Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, who has helped to expedite the registration process and promised to come to Johnstown to congratulate the first cohort of students next year. Shapiro has made workforce development—including apprenticeship—a priority, and this past spring, his administration announced an investment of more than $2.8M to boost apprenticeship enrollment.
But the state has been notoriously difficult when it comes to registering apprenticeships due to a 1961 law that requires an 11-member council appointed by the governor to approve every program. According to Zach Boren, senior vice president at Apprenticeships for America, this law has hampered growth while many other states have been expanding apprenticeship.
“Pennsylvania is one of the slowest-growing apprenticeship states nationally because they’ve set up bureaucratic hurdles to adopting apprenticeships,” Boren says. “The state has shown how to slow things down despite the governor’s wishes.”
The U.S. Department of Labor put states on notice earlier this year that it was going to be looking much more critically at these kinds of delays. The federal government has for almost 20 years said that in states that register apprenticeships themselves, such as Pennsylvania, the authority to approve programs lies with the state apprenticeship agencies, not advisory councils. But the rule has been loosely enforced.
Pennsylvania Highlands Community College, which is working with 1st Summit Bank to provide the education for apprentices, can attest to the impact. Steve Nunez, president of the college, says Penn Highlands started looking into registered apprenticeships a few years ago, but found that the process was “complex and convoluted.” The college abandoned its efforts temporarily and is just now resurrecting them with the 1st Summit Bank apprenticeship and a pre-apprenticeship program with TradesFutures.
The governor’s support of ASCEND 250 and a growing realization that higher ed is changing propelled Penn Highlands to get back on board with apprenticeships. The college also brought back a banking degree that had been sunset previously.
“We spent last year doing some deep introspection about who we are as an organization, and a lot of our employees and I felt that we need to provide an education that gives as many skills as possible to our graduates,” Nunez says. “We want our students to have more opportunities to not just learn in the classroom, but to apply it to their careers right away.”
Other community banks in the area are eagerly watching how ASCEND 250 unfolds. But for now the challenges of registering apprentices in small and midsize businesses, especially in Pennsylvania, are daunting. Boren suggests that smaller businesses band together and work with apprenticeship intermediaries to share resources and alleviate some of the administrative burden.
Preparing for AI
Like most industries today, banking is grappling with how the advent of artificial intelligence will change workforce needs. From a community-bank standpoint, Johnson says it won’t eliminate the need for humans, but it will change their role. She anticipates entry-level roles shrinking, but still wants trained workers for higher-level roles. She also wants to give local young people a chance to thrive in the industry instead of being left out.
“Who is going to be the human in the loop after my 30-year veterans have retired? That’s what we’re trying to solve for,” Johnson says. “If redundant tasks get replaced through AI, these kids will have a strong enough skill set to be able to think through that and have the human intelligence that’s needed.”
