In the recent Work Shift essay by the leaders of the Industry-Led Talent Initiative, “To Deliver Good Jobs, Governors Should Let Industry Describe the Destination,” the only standard given for determining what is a good job is what industry says. Yet for the past two years, the American Job Quality Study, led by Jobs for the Future and other research partners, has found that only about 40% of workers have jobs that qualify as good jobs.

Will industry say that only 40% of jobs are good? If workers and employers disagree about whether a job is in fact a good job, who should we believe? And does the public not have a point of view on this question? In considering this question of what a good job is, we at the Aspen Institute worked with a wide range of partners, who had a wide range of views. 

In terms of where taxpayer money is spent, the public sector’s interest in “good jobs” has been, in part, to reduce reliance on public benefits. So, if someone gets placed in what industry says is a good manufacturing job, but they are still eligible for SNAP and are unhappy about regularly being forced to work overtime at the last minute, are we nonetheless supposed to keep training people for manufacturing jobs because industry says they’re good?  

In addition, the aerospace example the authors cite reflects a common workforce mistake—assuming that industry will hire as many people in a position as are trained for it. They assume that industry can predict with perfect accuracy what it will need six months from now. But in six months the business may lose a big contract and not hire as many people as they expected. Or perhaps three regional community colleges develop programs and collectively train 200 people for what was only ever going to be 50 jobs. I have seen these and other scenarios happen, resulting in training that doesn’t achieve the advertised outcomes for many. Just because you can train lots of people for these jobs doesn’t mean there will be a job for everyone who completes the training. And of course, for those who dedicated their limited time and resources to training that didn’t land the kind of job that was expected, the consequences can be devastating. 

Workforce development also rarely looks at the labor market in its entirety. Leaders often focus on goods-producing sectors, such as manufacturing and construction, because their average wages are typically higher than those in service sectors. Yet these sectors account for only 16% of private employment, and their jobs vary considerably in quality. Workers may face seasonal or intermittent employment (common in construction), safety concerns, inflexible hours, and mandatory overtime—and wages are not uniformly high. Meanwhile, service sectors employ 84% of private-sector workers but receive far less attention outside healthcare. And within healthcare, there is too often the optimistic assumption that people will move up from entry-level roles, such as CNA or home health aide, and too little focus on how to improve the quality of work in those occupations. A strategy for good jobs needs to address the jobs most people actually hold.

Too often the experiences, needs, and concerns of working people are absent in this discourse. Workers are discussed as vessels for skills that employers want, with no agency, little humanity, and nothing to contribute to the conversation about how they might access decent employment and what barriers prevent that from happening now. I spent the early part of my career advocating for sector strategies. The whole point of the systems change aspect of sector strategies was to include more people in the benefits of a successful economy—to change the industry so that when things go well, success is shared. Yet negotiating to ensure that workforce services don’t just respond to the preferences of industry but also meet the needs of the people who do the work seems to have fallen by the wayside. 

I believe that good jobs are good business, and that there are opportunities to find “win-win” workforce solutions that improve both jobs and business outcomes. But we can’t achieve these outcomes if we only consider the interests of one side. 

Maureen Conway is vice president at the Aspen Institute and executive director of the institute’s Economic Opportunities Program.